11 Effective Strategies for Email List Maintenance and Cleaning
Is your email list losing its impact? To help you turn things around, we’ve gathered insights from Marketing leaders and CEOs who share their proven strategies for maintaining a clean, engaged list. From simplifying unsubscribe processes to using preference surveys to boost engagement, these eleven expert-backed tips will revolutionize the way you manage your email campaigns.
- Simplify Unsubscribe Processes
- Remove Inactive Subscribers Regularly
- Segment Based on Engagement
- Focus on Quality Over Quantity
- Quarterly Engagement Audits Boost Success
- Welcome Flow Enhances Inbox Placement
- Share Personal Experiences
- Run Preference Surveys
- Create Structure and Personalize
- Segment Out Unengaged Subscribers
- Double Opt-In and Regular Unsubscribe Invitations
Simplify Unsubscribe Processes
Counterintuitive as it may seem, I’ve found that making it easier for people to unsubscribe from our email list has been key to maintaining a healthy, engaged audience. We’ve embraced this “less is more” philosophy alongside sophisticated list hygiene practices to dramatically improve our email marketing performance.
Our maintenance strategy centers on three core practices:
- Regular list cleaning using specialized services like Zero Bounce
- Risk score assessment for each contact
- Simplified unsubscribe processes
The impact has been significant. After implementing these practices, particularly the email cleansing service, we’ve seen a marked improvement in our deliverability metrics across the board. Everything from opens to clicks to conversions is downstream of deliverability, I always say, “A smaller, engaged list will outperform a larger, unengaged one every time.”
For example, by using email validation services to identify and remove invalid addresses, we’ve not only avoided potential spam traps but also significantly improved our engagement rates. This white hat approach has proven essential for sustainable email marketing success in 2024.
Chris Reed
Executive Director of Marketing, Protect Line
Remove Inactive Subscribers Regularly
Maintain a healthy email list by regularly removing inactive subscribers, using a double opt-in process, and segmenting based on engagement levels. For example, after cleaning our list by removing unengaged contacts, our open rates increased by 15% and our deliverability improved significantly. This allowed us to focus on a more engaged audience, resulting in higher click-through rates and better overall campaign performance.
Vaibhav Namburi
Founder, Smartlead.ai
Segment Based on Engagement
We maintain a healthy email list by segmenting based on engagement and sending relevant content to active subscribers. Instead of just removing inactive contacts, we focus on tailoring follow-ups based on how subscribers interact with our emails. For example, when someone clicks on a specific product or content, we send them more targeted messages to keep them engaged.
A recent example is when we ran a “preference cleanup” campaign. Instead of removing inactive subscribers, we sent a simple survey asking users what content they wanted. 30% updated their preferences, and we used that data to segment the list. Afterwards, our open rates rose by 18%, and conversion rates for targeted campaigns went up by 12%. This approach made the list more valuable and relevant.
Roman Hipp
Co-Founder, BetterContact
Focus on Quality Over Quantity
Maintaining a healthy and engaged email list starts with consistent monitoring and focusing on quality over quantity. I prioritize segmenting lists based on activity and regularly removing inactive subscribers to ensure emails are reaching those who are genuinely interested. This keeps deliverability rates strong and engagement high.
We conducted a list cleaning project after noticing declining open rates. Identifying inactive subscribers who hadn’t engaged in over six months, we sent a re-engagement campaign asking if they still wanted to hear from us. Those who didn’t respond were removed. This reduced the list size by 15%, but open rates improved by 22%, and click-through rates increased by 18%.
Engaging with an audience that wants to hear from you not only strengthens metrics but also builds a stronger relationship with your subscribers.
V. Frank Sondors
Founder, Salesforge AI
Quarterly Engagement Audits Boost Success
The backbone of our email success at Thrive rests on quarterly engagement audits. Managing email campaigns taught me that a smaller, engaged list consistently outperforms a bloated one—especially when measuring real business impact.
We’ve made list hygiene a core part of our strategy. Each quarter, we segment subscribers based on six-month interaction history and run a targeted re-engagement campaign. After cleaning an e-commerce client’s list from 50,000 to 35,000 active subscribers, their revenue per email jumped significantly because we were reaching people who actually wanted to hear from them.
This focused approach isn’t just about better metrics—it saves money and protects sender reputation. When every email reaches an interested subscriber, campaigns naturally drive stronger results.
Aaron Whittaker
VP of Demand Generation & Marketing, Thrive Digital Marketing Agency
Welcome Flow Enhances Inbox Placement
Maintaining a healthy and engaged email list involves consistent monitoring and proactive management to ensure deliverability and relevance. One of our key practices is implementing a welcome flow designed not just for engagement but also for improving inbox placement. This flow includes eliciting replies from new subscribers, which helps signal to email providers that our communications are valuable and expected. We also focus on aligning timing and content across all active sequences to maintain consistency and avoid subscriber fatigue.
A specific example of this process in action is our work on rehabilitating inbox placement metrics. Initially, 29% of our emails were landing in spam folders. Through targeted efforts-such as the welcome flow and nurturing inactive subscribers with tailored value-driven content—we reduced spam rates to under 10%. These improvements directly boosted open and click-through rates, driving better engagement with our audience.
Aimie Ye
Director of Inbound Marketing, Centime
Share Personal Experiences
I’ve found that sharing personal strategies and experiences in my emails really keeps my subscribers engaged. I talk about everything from landing my first big client to the setbacks I’ve faced and the daily hurdles of running a business. By being open about my experiences, I make my emails more than just advice; they become relatable stories that inspire and resonate. This transparency helps my clients see themselves in my journey, creating a stronger bond and helping them to look forward to every email I send.
A real game-changer for me was the day I decided to clean up my email list. I launched a re-engagement campaign and said goodbye to subscribers who hadn’t been actively engaged with me and my brand. The payoff was great, as my email deliverability improved, and my messages started hitting the mark more consistently. This experience reinforced to me that quality trumps quantity. Having a smaller, but more involved group of subscribers is far more valuable than a larger, disinterested audience.
Run Preference Surveys
We regularly run “preference surveys” to ask subscribers what type of content they value most—case studies, SEO tips, or broader digital trends—and adjust our content accordingly. This ensures we’re delivering value based on what they actually want, not what we assume they want. It’s all about aligning expectations with delivery.
During one clean-up effort, we identified that nearly 10% of our list consisted of outdated corporate emails. Removing these addresses immediately reduced hard bounces and complaints, which had been quietly affecting our performance metrics. It was like removing hidden friction that was holding our campaigns back.
Jason Hennessey
CEO, Hennessey Digital
Create Structure and Personalize
The main thing you need to do is create structure. This means regularly reviewing your email list and removing inactive users. This will save you unnecessary effort that you spend on sending emails to those users who don’t engage with it. At the same time, you’ll be able to focus more on users who are actually interested in what you have to offer. Plus, you’ll have a clearer idea about the results of your email marketing efforts.
To keep your users engaged, however, you should perfect your personalization strategy. To do that, you need to review the engagement metrics of your emails and segment your audience. For instance, there can be active users who always engage with your emails, but also users who do so rarely. These two groups, therefore, need two different approaches. Based on this data, you can personalize emails for those segments to, for example, include special deals and alerts for more passive users.
By doing this, we saw, first, an increase in productivity and the overall improvement in the results of email marketing. But also, by personalizing our emails, we saw a 15% increase in open rates.
Daria Shevchenko
CMO at Snov.Io, Snov.io
Segment Out Unengaged Subscribers
Segmentation is the key to maintaining a healthy and engaged list.
Email marketing, much like all of sales and marketing, is a numbers game. If people are consistently ignoring your emails, you’re wasting your time and money by sending them more emails. Send them a final offer and sunset them out of your main list, so that you can focus on marketing to the subscribers who want to hear from you.
Doing this will naturally increase your open, click and conversion rates, because you’re no longer emailing people who would ignore them.
Are people spam filtering or hard bouncing your emails? Segment them out of your list. Emailing them further will only hurt your sender reputation, which may even lower your engagement metrics over time.
Do you have a lot of people who receive your emails but aren’t opening or clicking them? Segment them out of your main emails and only send them your best offers. If they won’t shop your best offers, they probably won’t ever shop with you. Cut your losses and move on.
Kar Lo
Email Marketing Specialist, Lo Marketing Company
Double Opt-In and Regular Unsubscribe Invitations
First of all, we ask for permission by prompting a double opt-in.
After you sign up, you’ll receive an email to confirm your email address. If you don’t confirm, you won’t get emailed. It’s that simple.
That takes our bounce rate down to nearly zero. Of course, some people use business emails to sign up and their website may go offline one day. Eventually, some emails will still bounce.
I digress.
Other than that, we regularly invite our email list to unsubscribe. This goes beyond the opt-out/unsubscribe link at the bottom of the email.
At the top of the email, we’ll ask them that if they’re no longer finding value in our emails, they can opt out.
Another thing we do related to this is allow folks to opt out of specific promotions. For example, if we know we’re about to do a Christmas sale, we’ll add people to that list. At the top, we’ll let them know we’ll be increasing the frequency of emails over the next few days/weeks. If they’re not interested in this promotion, they can click a link and they’ll only get their regular emails.
The last thing we do, once every six months, is clean out inactive users (folks who haven’t engaged for three months or more). We’ll send them through a reactivation sequence that lasts one month. If they don’t make it through, they’re unsubscribed from all lists at the end.
Because of our conscious efforts, our open rates are consistently high (40%+), we get a lot of replies to our emails, and we have almost no negative unsubscribe notices.
Felix Yim
Cofounder and Marketing Director Humanize AI, Humanize AI
Submit Your Answer
Would you like to submit an alternate answer to the question, “What practices do you follow to maintain a healthy and engaged email list? Can you share one example of how cleaning your list improved your email marketing metrics?”
